Majority of councillors back Pink Rabbit Club, but refusal stands and ratepayers will foot the bill
MEDIA STATEMENT
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE · Nov 18, 2026
Pink Rabbit is deeply disappointed that the City of Perth Council last night failed to approve the revised Pink Rabbit Club proposal (Item 11.3, Ordinary Council Meeting, 17 November 2026).
The motion to approve was carried 3–2 by the councillors who voted. Because it needed an absolute majority, it was lost. The City will now go back to the State Administrative Tribunal to defend a refusal that its own planning officers do not support, that most councillors present voted against, and that councillors were told three planning firms had advised would be immensely difficult to defend.
This follows mediation at the Tribunal, where Pink Rabbit agreed to reduced capacity, stricter membership conditions and an approval limited to five years.
Councillor Gobbert set out the law
Councillor Liam Gobbert, the only qualified planner on council, explained clearly why the application should be approved. He said there did not "appear to be any merit to exercising discretion to refuse", and that on amenity, "it is not sufficient to simply state that there is an impact. It needs to be demonstrated how."
He reminded the chamber that "the law outweighs opinions, and we do not pick and choose what parts of it to follow," and added: "I also don't believe we should be picking and choosing where inclusion belongs in our city."
Cr Gobbert also said that, in his professional view, Pink Rabbit did not need to make any concessions in mediation, and that he could see an appeal succeeding on established Tribunal precedent. We thank him for keeping the debate on the planning merits, where it belongs.
The Lord Mayor's own test
Opening the debate, the Lord Mayor agreed that this "is not a moral decision", that it is "a planning decision governed by planning legislation", and that "we must determine the application before us on its planning merits."
Closing the debate, he described the comments of all three supporting councillors as "well founded". He then said he was "just built a certain way" and could not approve something he did not agree with, adding: "that's just the way it is, unfortunately."
With respect, "that's just the way it is" is not a planning ground. Councillors decide applications like this in a quasi-judicial role, and the applicant and ratepayers are entitled to a reasoned decision. By his own test, and having accepted that the case for approval was well founded, the Lord Mayor should have voted to approve.
Councillor Ko and the City's own LGBTQIA+ plan
Councillor Viktor Ko said he could not support the application because the City's LGBTQI plan for 2025–2029, which supports safe spaces for LGBTQIA+ people, does not specifically prescribe a permanent, members-only venue.
We respectfully say that reading gets the plan backwards. The plan supports safe spaces for LGBTQIA+ people, and nothing in it rules this one out. A plan that doesn't name a type of venue doesn't prohibit it. Development applications are decided under the planning scheme, and the City's officers found this one complies. Cr Ko described his vote as keeping a promise to the LGBTQIA+ community. That promise is better kept by supporting a safe, regulated space that members of that community have asked for.
A poor use of ratepayers' money
Councillor Chris Patton voted against the proposal in July. Last night he said his personal view had not changed, but he voted to approve because he did not believe the City could defend a refusal:
"I'm not comfortable putting ratepayers through a lengthy and expensive legal battle … when I believe there'll be a real likelihood that the city will lose. That's not a responsible use of ratepayers' money."
Councillor Lisa Ma told the meeting the City has already spent around $10,000 on this matter, with a further $30,000 to $50,000 estimated for a full hearing, plus considerable staff time. She said those resources would be better spent on services such as CCTV, night patrols, lighting and cleaning. We agree.
Two votes have now committed the City to a Tribunal hearing its own advisers expect it to lose.
Comment from Nick Needham, Managing Director, Pink Rabbit
"A majority of councillors in the room voted yes. The City's planners said yes. Three planning firms told the City it would struggle to defend a refusal. And still we're headed back to the Tribunal."
"I want to thank Councillor Gobbert, Councillor Patton and Councillor Ma for deciding this on the evidence. We did everything that was asked of us: we went to mediation and came back with a smaller, tighter proposal. This was always about giving people a safe, regulated, respectful place to connect, and we'll keep making that case."